Caroline's Cakes Review

Caroline's Cakes Review 2024 → Best Traditional Southern Cakes Ever!

E. T. Kazaene 5.0 / 5 ratings 156 readers

About Caroline's Cakes

Organizing an event is not complete without serving a specialty cake. Caroline’s Cakes offers you a Southern layer cake with handmade authenticity.

Caroline's Cakes Review: About Caroline's Cakes

Its ingredients feature a nut-free concept, and the owner has made the cake for decades. The bakery is not only famous for its 7-layer nut-free cake.

However, it’s also famous for tons of cakes with ingredients that are friendly to people with specific allergies, such as gluten-free.

Further, the shop has marketed the cakes nationwide for over 41 years since 1982. As the company grew, the bakery owner registered his cakes with Food Allergy Initiative in 1998.

That’s not all. It has participated in serving the cake in many charity programs, including Allendale Association, Jackson Hore Conservation Alliance, Lenox Hill Neighbourhood House, Leukemia & Lymphoma Society, and many more.

Also, Oprah Winfrey has given her best review for the cakes from Caroline’s. As a result, the bakery gets many followers on their social media, 120k on Facebook and 28k on Instagram.

What’s more? We will give you essential info about Caroline’s Cakes Review, but we invite you to get to know the bakery’s story first. Check this out!

Overview of Caroline's Cakes

The owner of Caroline’s Cakes is Caroline Ragsdale Reutter. Caroline lived in and grew up in Lake City, South Carolina. Although her major isn’t in baking but actually in interior design, her love of food is at her heart.

Besides that, she began selling to her customers from her grandfather’s charcoal business. In fact, the bakery remained unknown from when it opened the shop first.

But, the legendary 7-Layer Caramel Cake was introduced ever when Caroline’s youngest son celebrated his Christening in 1982

After that event, she had an order mail from Alaskan and Hawaiian customers. And with the many requests they’ve encountered throughout Caroline’s Cakes history, making them for inventing more cakes!

As a result, they have known for their premium nut-free cakes and have made a lot of variants of traditional Southern layer cakes as of now. We will present you below to learn more about what layer cakes they sell.

Caroline's Cakes Review

Caroline has specialization in handmade, bespoke cakes for personal celebrations and corporate. By far, they use only the finest, freshest ingredients to create their cakes.

Caroline's Cakes Reviews: Caroline's Cakes Review

While the nut-free 7-layer cake is the specialty of this bakery, the other tarts are also delicious to try. To note, all variants are zero nuts!

As you will find, the brand offers millions of cakes with Southern signatures and with 4 and 7 choice layers.

There are occasional cakes, flavorful cakes, Oprah’s favorites, custom cakes, cake bites, and half-cakes.

Caroline’s Cakes Products

Occasional cakes
Flavorful cakes
Custom cakes


  • Fresh, high-quality ingredients
  • Personal touch
  • Wide variety of cakes
  • Convenient ordering and delivery

Moreover, we won’t take about all of those tarts simultaneously. However, we will present you with their best-selling cakes. There are 7-layer caramel cakes, pink champagne cake, and caramel cake bites to accompany your lovely day!

Caroline's Cakes 7-Layer Caramel Cake Reviews

The first most-purchased cake on the menu we will present you is the 7-Layer Caramel Cake. What’s unique about this cake is that it’s the legend of the cake shop.

Caroline's Cakes Review: Caroline's Cakes 7-Layer Caramel Cake Reviews

You might not believe that this cake has been around for decades! And FYI! The 7-layer caramel cake recipe remains hidden to maintain the quality.

With this old age, this patty has a diameter of 9 centimeters which is suitable for serving 14 to 20 guests And, if the cake leaves you a slice, that can still be stored for up to 6 months.

Additionally, this cake is made with moist yellow cake layers free from nuts. Then one ingredient that makes it more flavorful is that the cake combines brown sugar and sugar.

It makes fewer sweets than typical layer cakes you find. This makes you feel the “melt-in-your-mouth” caramel icing.

Then, to purchase this legend tart, you must only afford it for around $70. Now, you can taste the spectacular cake you won’t ever regret!

Caroline's Cakes Pink Champagne Cake Reviews

The second must-purchased selection you may find fascinating to taste is Pink Champagne Cake. We would say that this cake is suitable for presenting as your birthday cake.

Caroline's Cakes Review: Caroline's Cakes Pink Champagne Cake Reviews

In fact, the cake is 9 diameters long and has 4 layers in one size, making it suitable to serve 14 to 20 people. It can refreeze in the refrigerator for 6 months long.

Additionally, this is made with 4 layers of sponge cake to form a charming sparkle look. As well the pink champagne cake is filled and iced with rosé-colored buttercream. Then, as we mentioned, you shouldn’t worry since the ingredients inside don’t contain nuts.

At last, to get this eye-catching, light, and airy tart, you must pay only $70. With the best price, you can taste the premium yet flavorful cake in size.

Caroline's Cakes Caramel Cake Bites Reviews

We hope the last two cakes weren’t enough to be served at your event. We recommend Caramel Cake Bites, perfect for formal or informal occasions. These small sizes are made with unique caramel cake recipes.

Caroline's Cakes Review: Caroline's Cakes Caramel Cake Bites Reviews

And as you can see in the photos above, it’s made with caramel and dipped in white chocolate. Made with sugar and hydrogenated palm kernel oil, make it savoring. Having a cute look makes it easy to digest!

Again, as we delivered, the cake is free from nuts so that everyone can enjoy this cake! While it can be stored in the freezer, it’s also perfect for serving your friends, family, and kids. 

In addition, by purchasing it for $25, you will get 12 pieces per box. It’s ideal for your snack while watching your favorite series.

Caroline's Cakes Pros and Cons

We’re thrilled to give you some pros and cons for Caroline’s Cakes, so you’ll be convinced to check it out!


  • Best prices
  • Various options
  • Nut-free & Gluten-free options
  • Recognized by the Food Allergy Initiative
  • Custom available
  • Shipping nationwide
  • Refund available
  • Featured in several renowned charities
  • Has been reviewed by Oprah Winfrey


  • Can’t be shipped internationally
  • Currently no free shipping

Who Is Caroline's Cakes For?

These special cakes are for everyone, especially for cake lovers! All of the cakes are right for them. In addition, for those who don’t like sweets and nuts, you are highly suggested to try them. We ensure you’ll like it!

Caroline's Cakes Review: Who Is Caroline's Cakes For?

Further, we highly urge those looking for a high-quality cake made with fresh, high-quality ingredients to buy all the items.

In addition, for those who usually hold an event and looking for a delicious and unique cake for a special occasion on weekends, all variants are excellent choices for celebrating your experience with your loved ones, family, or colleagues!

Caroline's Cakes Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

By getting to know the most purchased cakes, we will be happier if you can get to know the testimonials from customers who have already tried them.

Caroline's Cakes Review: Caroline's Cakes Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

The 3 positive reviews we found on the website hope can satisfy you. Hence, you buy Caroline’s bread immediately.

So, the first buyer, who successfully purchased the 7-Layer Caramel Cake, said the cake was their best choice. They praised the texture of the cake and the excellent delivery. The customer gave 5/5 ratings. They said:

The caramel cake is a dream come true! Rich, moist and impressive! It’s great service, arrived in fast and in sustainable packaging, definitely order this for every special occasion!

Furthermore, another customer revealed that the cake had a perfect look, making her not share it. It’s too precious to slice it.

She got the Pink Champagne cake from her partner to celebrate Valentine’s Day. She gave 5/5 ratings. The shopper commented

I was asked, “Chocolates or champagne” and obviously had to choose champagne, and I’m happy I did this. The cake not only arrived looking gorgeous but tasted amazing! I almost didn’t want to share! …

Then, this third shopper delivered that aside from the taste, which is delicious, also the cake was in the exact size to eat as the name suggests.

Although the customer didn’t buy but got the Caramel Cake Bites as a gift, They were happy and rated 5 out of 5. They revealed:

A dear mate granted these to us for Christmas. They are awesome! Just the right dimension to fulfil a sweet tooth.

Overall, all of them are pleased with the cakes. They are satisfied with the flavor, appearance, and size. Also, their service in shipping the cake makes them happy.

It is wrapped tidily so that the cake comes in perfect condition. The cakes are also fit for celebrating any occasion or event they trust.

Is Caroline's Cakes Worth It?

We won’t dare to recommend all three cakes from Caroline’s Cakes if it’s not worth it! From the legendary one to the bite cake, all are tasty! Any flavors are available to send to your house or as a gift. 

Caroline's Cakes Review: Is Caroline's Cakes Worth It?

Furthermore, the premium cakes with the best prices you want are all in one place at Caroline’s. No worries anymore about the ingredients inside the products since it uses free nuts. Suitable for the nuts’ allergist!

Also, we found that the company currently hasn’t provided information related to shark tank or other things.

Caroline's Cakes Shipping Policy

Fortunately, the bakery offers a shipping method within 3 days nationwide, including 50 states in the U.S. and Columbia District states.

However, due to the perishable items, it may take time to ship to your door. Here’s the shipping system you may need to know.

  • All perishable items are shipped via UPS
  • Cannot ship to P.O. Boxes, APO, or FPO addresses
  • Available time Monday- Friday between the hours of 8:30 am – 5:00 pm EST
  • All of the cakes are shipped with dry ice to maintain freshness
  • Saturday delivery is available in specific areas
  • Available ordering in holidays, but suggested early 

Caroline's Cakes Return Policy

Luckily, they provide cancellations and refunds. It requires a minimum of 48 hours after ordering. However, we suggest you ensure the order first, whether it’s been shipped or not. If so, they will not accept it.

We also advise you to contact them first before making any return. If damaged items are sent after you open them for the first time, they will refund them in 30 days. We ensure their cakes are original and delicious, like their looks. 

How To Contact Caroline's Cakes?

There are various ways to reach Caroline’s Cakes. And the online service may not be available at weekends, so ensure to reach by these business hours.

  • Monday – Thursday: 8:30 am-5:00pm
  • Friday: 9:00 am-5:00 pm

In addition, the contact you can get is below to order all the delicious cakes from the store!

  • Email: [email protected]
  • Phone number 1: (888) 801-2253 for local 
  • Phone number 2: 888-801-CAKE (2253) for Toll-free 
  • Fill out the form on the contact us page of the official website

Then, here are social media to follow and to get to know their latest info.

  • Facebook: Caroline’s Cakes
  • Instagram: @carolinescakes
  • Twitter: @carolinescakes

Bakery Address

925 Beaumont Avenue
Spartanburg, SC

Where to buy Caroline's Cakes?

You must be wondering if your locations are near me from the cake shop. Don’t worry. It’s fortunate that currently, you can purchase through the official website.

Additionally, Caroline’s Cakes’ official website lets shoppers browse the bakery’s cakes, cupcakes, pies, and other pastries. You can also request their cakes with different flavors, icings, and decorations.

However, you can visit Caroline’s Cakes to see their freshest cakes from the oven. The store has a physical location in Spartanburg, South Carolina. The bakery’s opening hours are usually Monday to Friday from 9 am to 6 pm, Saturday from 9 am to 5 pm, and Sunday from 12 pm to 4 pm.

Otherwise, you can find it easily by calling by phone at 888-801-2253. Moreover, you can visit Amazon, Goldbelly, or Yelp to order all the delicious cakes and other online local stores near your house!

Caroline's Cakes Coupon Codes & Promos

With all the services and delicious cakes to pamper you, this brand doesn’t want to miss out on giving you another special treatment: discount offers.

We’ve gathered some info just for you!

  • Signing up and add SMS messaging to obtain 10% Off
  • 10% Off deal for particular cakes
  • Join their affiliate program to get a 15% commission rate

In addition, you can also try signing up first to learn about other significant discounts and coupon codes.

Reveal all coupons
Caroline's Cakes

Caroline's Cakes Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

When looking for Caroline's Cakes reviews, customers typically ask the following questions. We provide the answers to help you in making a smart purchase decision.

Who Owns Caroline's Cakes?

Caroline Ragsdale Reutter is the owner of Caroline’s Cakes.

What is the history of Caroline's Cakes?

The first time the legendary cake, a 7-layer Caramel Cake, was introduced to the church’s congregation at the event of her youngest son’s Christening in 1982.

Where is Caroline's Cakes Located?

You can visit Caroline’s Cakes at 925 Beaumont Avenue, Spartanburg, SC 29303. The opening hours of the shop are from Monday to Friday from 9 am to 6 pm, Saturday from 9 am to 5 pm, and Sunday from 12 pm to 4 pm.

Ask a question?

Conclusion of Caroline's Cakes Reviews & Ratings

Caroline’s Cakes is the perfect choice to celebrate any occasion. Serving you with many options, 4-7 layers of cakes with nut-free ingredients make your all guests can eat it.

Moreover, you won’t be hesitant since it’s existed for over 40 years and has been registered for a long time in Food Allergy Initiative. Now, choose your favorite cakes!


We're reader-supported. Oh, and FYI When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission from the links on this page.